The utility of microspheres as surrogates for the transport of E. coli RS2g in partially saturated agricultural soil

Abstract

Polystyrene latex microspheres are widely used as surrogates for biocolloid transport in porous media; however, relatively few studies directly compare microsphere transport with that of the microorganism it is intended to represent, particularly at the field scale. Here, we compared the transport behaviour of a bacterium (Escherichia coli RS2g; 1.2 microm in diameter) and three different sized microspheres (1.1, 3.9, and 4.8 microm in diameter) within undisturbed agricultural field soil following infiltration under partially saturated conditions. The soil contained significant macroporosity. A tension infiltrometer was used to control the application of a transport solution containing Brilliant Blue FCF dye to two plots. A >2 log reduction in the concentration of all colloids was observed from the soil surface to 5 cm depth in both plots. The concentration of colloids in the soil was generally proportional to the intensity of soil dye staining; however, both the E. coli RS2g bacterium and the 1.1 microm microspheres appeared to be transported deeper than the other colloids and the visible dye along root holes at the bottom of the profile in both plots. The similarities in size and zeta potential of the 1.1 microm microspheres and the E. coli RS2g likely contributed to that outcome. Colloid concentrations in dyed soil by depth were similar between the two plots, despite differences in soil properties and infiltration patterns. The properties of the colloids and macropore density were the most important factors affecting colloid transport. These results suggest that microspheres with size and surface properties similar to the microbe of interest are useful surrogates to trace potential pathways of transport in the subsurface.