Cobalamin C (cblC) disease, an inborn error of vitamin B(12) metabolism, results in neurometabolic, neurochemical and neuroanatomical changes. Little is known of the long-term effects of the disorder on cognition and behaviour in children. Here, the complete neuropsychological profiles of two 12-year-old girls with cblC disease are presented. The two girls were tested longitudinally with standardized neuropsychological tests including intellectual ability, attention and memory, as well as executive, adaptive and behavioural function. The results indicate the presence of intellectual dysfunction, attention problems, and concerns with behavioural aspects of executive function. Both patients demonstrated a pattern of decreasing intellectual function over time, which may reflect a growing developmental gap in comparison with their same age peers. These impairments are in contrast to the relatively spared verbal expression and comprehension abilities, as well as strengths in sociability. The findings highlight a pattern of neuropsychological strengths and weaknesses that may distinguish cblC disease from other inborn errors of metabolism. Overt sociability such as observed in these two patients may actually mask underlying cognitive deficits because the patients appear to function at a more advanced level than that reflected by quantitative assessment of intellectual and cognitive functioning. This is of clinical and functional importance and suggests that accurate determination of cognitive, adaptive and social abilities necessitates an in-depth and broad evaluation. The presence of significant intellectual and cognitive deficits also underscores the need to document and monitor cognitive development in children with cblC disease and to consider remediative and adaptive learning strategies.