Ion pair "leakage" pathways, located computationally by means of multidimensional potential energy surface scans, rationalize the unsymmetrical D-label scrambling observed experimentally in the DCl addition products of nortricyclene and norbornene. "Classical" addition transition structures can interconvert ("leak") to symmetrical nonclassical 2-norbornyl ion pair species, either TS's or a minimum, before products form.