Split G-rich DNA probes can assemble into active peroxidase-mimicking DNAzymes in the presence of bioanalytes such as DNA, thereby providing a simple and cheap means to detect analytes in biological samples. A comprehensive study designed to reveal the salient probe architectural features and reaction conditions that facilitate facile reconstitution into enzymatically proficient enzymes unveiled these important findings: (a) The loops that connect the G3-tracts in a G-quadruplex structure can be replaced with a stem-loop or loop-stem-loop motif without destabilizing the resulting quadruplex structure; endowing the split G-rich probes with regions of limited complementarity leads to more proficient reconstituted enzymes. (b) The addition of hemin to antiparallel G-quadruplex DNAzymes lead to a blue shift in the CD spectra of the G-quadruplex DNAzymes. (c) The architectures of the DNA motifs that lie adjacent to the G-quadruplex structure influence both the stability and the enzymatic proficiency of the reconstituted enzymes. (d) The nature of the monovalent cation that is present in excess is a key determinant of the turnover number of the G-quadruplex DNAzyme; decomposition of G-quadruplex DNAzymes is slower in buffers that contain ammonium ions than those that contain sodium or potassium ions. These findings are important for the design of bioassays that use peroxidase-mimicking G-quadruplexes as detection labels.