Several specimens of an aecial rust fungus were collected on Senecio madagascariensis during a field survey carried out in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. As telia were not present in the specimens collected, DNA sequence analyses were undertaken to determine the identity of the rust species. ITS and beta-tub1 sequencing confirmed that one of the isolates recovered is Puccinia lagenophorae sensu lato. On the other hand, sequencing and RFLP analysis revealed the presence of two divergent copies of ITS and beta-tub1 in all the other six isolates investigated. In both phylogenetic trees, one copy of the gene region grouped within a well supported clade with sequences of P. lagenophorae accessions from different geographical origins and hosts, and the Australian rusts Puccinia saccardoi and Puccinia stylidii. The other copy of these gene regions grouped within a separate clade comprising European accessions of Puccinia dioicae (ITS) and Uromyces sommerfeltii (beta-tub1) that occur on Asteraceae hosts. Multiple copies of these gene regions were not observed in Australian isolates of P. lagenophorae. Our study provides some evidence that an interspecific hybrid rust fungus, with P. lagenophorae as one of its parents, may occur on S. madagascariensis in South Africa. The identity of the other parent remains unknown.