7,8-Dihydro-8-oxoguanine (8-oxoG) is a ubiquitous oxidative DNA lesion resulting from injury to DNA via reactive oxygen species. 8-oxoG lesions may play a role in the formation of aberrant DNA methylation patterns during carcinogenesis. In this study, we assessed the effects of 8-oxoG on methylation and complex formation of nine 30-mer oligodeoxynucleotide duplexes by the catalytic domain of murine Dnmt3a DNA methyltransferase (Dnmt3a-CD). The effects of 8-oxoG on the methylation rate of hemimethylated duplexes varied from a 25-fold decrease to a 1.8-fold increase, depending on the position of the lesion relative to the Dnmt3a-CD recognition site (CpG) and target cytosine (C). The most significant effect was observed when 8-oxoG replaced guanine within the recognition site immediately downstream of the target cytosine. Fluorescence polarization experiments with fluorescein-labeled duplexes revealed that two molecules of Dnmt3a-CD bind per duplex, generating sigmoid binding curves. Duplexes exhibiting the highest apparent binding cooperativity formed the least stable 1:2 complexes with Dnmt3a-CD and were methylated at the lowest rate. Kinetic analyses disclosed the formation of very stable nonproductive enzyme-substrate complexes with hemimethylated duplexes that act as suicide substrates of Dnmt3a-CD. The presence of 8-oxoG within the CpG site downstream of the target cytosine markedly diminished productive versus nonproductive binding. We propose that 8-oxoG located adjacent to the target cytosine interferes with methylation by weakening the affinity of DNA for Dnmt3a-CD, thereby favoring a nonproductive binding mode.