Oxidative modification of alpha-synuclein (alphaSyn) was reported to have significant effects on its amyloidogenic properties. Dicarbonyl compounds are metabolites accumulated by various oxidative processes in the intracellular environment. In this study, two dicarbonyl compounds, methylglyoxal (MGO) and glyoxal (GO), were investigated for their effects on the structural and fibril-forming properties of alphaSyn. Both compounds were found to induce the oligomerization of alphaSyn. By adding substoichiometric amounts of alphaSyn modified by MGO or GO, the fibrillization of alphaSyn was substantially inhibited. The heterogeneously-modified alphaSyns were separated into three fractions: monomers, oligomers, and high molecular mass oligomers. When each modified alphaSyn species was used to seed fibril formation, protein fibrillization was significantly suppressed. Temperature scanning and interactions with liposomes revealed that both MGO- and GO-modified monomers were not as susceptible as the unmodified alphaSyn to conformational changes into partially folded intermediates and alpha-helixes. Our observations suggest that dicarbonyl modification of alphaSyn reduces conformational flexibility of the protein, thereby contributing to a reduction in the ability of alphaSyn to form fibrils, and the modified protein inhibits the fibrillization of the unmodified alphaSyn.