The tumor suppressor p53 controls a broad range of cellular responses. Induction of a transient (cell cycle arrest) or a permanent (senescence) block of cell proliferation, or the activation of cell death pathways in response to genotoxic stress comprise the major arms of the survival-death axis governed by p53. Due to these biological properties, inactivation of p53 is a crucial step in tumor development and progression, reflected by the high incidence of TP53 mutations in different types of human cancers. The remarkable potency of p53 in suppressing tumorigenic outgrowth has promoted the expectation that tumor cells expressing wild-type p53 (wtp53) should be more prone to elimination by cytotoxic treatments than tumor cells expressing mutant p53 (mutp53) with defunct wtp53 activities. However, recent findings yielded somewhat unexpected insights concerning the preponderance of the survival-promoting effects of wtp53 in cancer cells, a rather undesired property from the therapeutic point of view. In this commentary we will discuss the possibility that the developmentally established distinct patterns of wtp53 mediated responses in different tissues are an important factor in determining the ultimate outcome of cellular responses mediated by wtp53 in different types of tumor cells, with a particular focus on the divergent impact of wtp53 in malignant tumors of the central nervous system. We infer that a selective gain of pro-survival functions of wtp53 in cancer cells will confer a survival advantage that counteracts tumor therapy.