Serum is a difficult matrix for the identification of biomarkers by mass spectrometry (MS). This is due to high-abundance proteins and their complex processing by a multitude of endogenous proteases making rigorous standardisation difficult. Here, we have investigated the use of defined exogenous reporter peptides as substrates for disease-specific proteases with respect to improved standardisation and disease classification accuracy. A recombinant N-terminal fragment of the Adenomatous Polyposis Coli (APC) protein was digested with trypsin to yield a peptide mixture for subsequent Reporter Peptide Spiking (RPS) of serum. Different preanalytical handling of serum samples was simulated by storage of serum samples for up to 6 h at ambient temperature, followed by RPS, further incubation under standardised conditions and testing for stability of protease-generated MS profiles. To demonstrate the superior classification accuracy achieved by RPS, a pilot profiling experiment was performed using serum specimens from pancreatic cancer patients (n = 50) and healthy controls (n = 50). After RPS six different peak categories could be defined, two of which (categories C and D) are modulated by endogenous proteases. These latter are relevant for improved classification accuracy as shown by enhanced disease-specific classification from 78% to 87% in unspiked and spiked samples, respectively. Peaks of these categories presented with unchanged signal intensities regardless of preanalytical conditions. The use of RPS generally improved the signal intensities of protease-generated peptide peaks. RPS circumvents preanalytical variabilities and improves classification accuracies. Our approach will be helpful to introduce MS-based proteomic profiling into routine laboratory testing.