Here we report on a large brachyuran crab species from the Late Cretaceous of Mexico that has claws indicative of highly specialized shell-breaking behaviour. This crab possessed dimorphic claws (the right larger than the left), armed with several broad teeth, including a curved tooth structure found at the base of the movable finger of the right claw. The curved tooth is similar to the one observed on claws of many living durophagous crabs that use it as a weapon to peel, crush or chip the edges of hard-shelled prey, particularly molluscs. These morphological traits suggest that specialized shell-breaking crab predators had evolved during the Cretaceous, which contradicts previous findings supporting an Early Cenozoic origin for specialized shell crushers within the brachyuran clade.