U-shaped response has been frequently encountered in various biological areas including epidemiology, toxicology, and oncology. Despite its frequent observation, the theory of U-shaped response has been crippled by the lack of a robust mechanism underlying and incomplete in vitro and in vivo correlation. In the present study, a novel mechanism is provided for a U-shaped response, based on the findings of agonist-induced vasomotor tone change affected by menadione (MEN) (synthetic vitamin K(3)), a reactive oxygen species generator, and arsenic, an environmental pollutant, which showed typical U-shaped responses in both in vitro aortic contractile response and in vivo blood pressure. U-shaped responses by MEN and arsenic were a combined result from heterogenic susceptibilities and responses of multiple target cells composing blood vessels, that is, endothelium and smooth muscle. Notably, endothelium, a regulator of vasomotor tone, was primarily affected by low-dose stimuli, whereas smooth muscle, an effector of vascular contraction, was affected later by high-dose. The dysfunction of smooth muscle was produced by high-dose MEN-induced hydrogen peroxide, resulting in the attenuation of vascular contractile reactivity, whereas low-dose MEN-induced superoxide led to the quenching of vasodilatory nitric oxide in endothelial cells, resulting in the enhancement of vasoconstriction. This mechanistic theory, the difference in susceptibilities and responses to a common stimulus between regulator and effector components of a system, could give a new insight into the explanation of various U-shaped responses and provide a new evidence for the need of the risk assessment of toxicants with a wider dose range.