The singlet oxygen formation quantum yield (Phi(Delta)) for solutions of the di-cation, free-base and metallated forms of hematoporphyrin derivative (HpD), hematoporphyrin IX (Hp9) and a boronated protoporphyrin (BOPP) are reported using the method of direct detection of the characteristic phosphorescence following polychromatic excitation. Values of Phi(Delta) for the free-base form of all the porphyrins and the di-cation forms of Hp9 and HpD are in the range of 0.44 to 0.85 in the solvents investigated. Incorporation of zinc ions into the macrocycle reduces Phi(Delta) for all three porphyrins. BOPP facilitates the coordination of certain transition metals (Mn, Co and Cu) compared to Hp9 and HpD and results in a dramatic decrease in Phi(Delta). The experimental data suggest the introduction of low energy charge transfer states associated with the disruption of the planarity of the macrocyclic ring provides alternative non-radiative deactivation pathways. In BOPP, this non-planarity is augmented by the large closo-carborane peripheral substituent groups.