Internalization of the PTH type I receptor (PTH1R) is regulated in a cell- and ligand-specific manner. We previously demonstrated that the sodium/proton exchanger regulatory factor type 1 (NHERF1; EBP50) is pivotal in determining the range of peptides that internalize the PTH1R. Antagonist PTH fragments can internalize the PTH1R in some kidney and bone cell models. PTH(7-34), which binds to, but does not activate, the PTH1R, internalizes the PTH1R in kidney distal tubule (DT) cells, where NHERF1 is not expressed. The effect of antagonist PTHrP peptides has not, to this point, been assessed. PTH1R internalization was measured by real-time confocal fluorescence microscopy of DT cells stably expressing 105 EGFP-tagged PTH1R/cell. PTHrP(7-34) internalized the PTH1R in a manner indistinguishable from PTH(7-34). Introduction of NHERF1 into DT cells, however, blocked PTH(7-34)-, but not PTHrP(7-34)-, induced PTH1R internalization. To delineate the sequences within PTHrP that determine whether PTH1R internalization is affected by NHERF1, chimeric PTH/PTHrP fragments were tested for their ability to induce PTH1R internalization. PTH(7-21)/PTHrP (22-34), PTH(7-32)/PTHrP(33-34), and PTH(7-33)/PTHrP(34) at 1 microM each internalized the PTH1R 50-70% in a NHERF1-independent manner. When the C terminus of PTHrP was replaced with homologous amino acids from PTH, NHERF1 inhibited PTH1R internalization. It was determined that simply mutating F34 to A in PTH induced PTH1R internalization in a NHERF1-independent manner. None of the chimeric peptides activated the PTH1R but all effectively competed for 1 nM PTH(1-34) in cyclic AMP assays. In addition, all chimeric peptides competed for radiolabeled PTH(1-34) in binding assays in DT cells. PTH(1- 34) and PTHrP(7-34), but not PTH(7-34), efficiently recruited beta-arrestin1 to plasma membrane PTH1Rs. We, therefore, conclude that PTH(1-34) and PTHrP(7-34) induce a conformational change in the PTH1R that promotes arrestin binding and dissociates NHERF1 from PTH1R internalization.