Genetic exchange by asexual filamentous fungi is presumed to be limited to isolates in the same vegetative compatibility group (VCG). To evaluate genetic isolation of Aspergillus flavus due to vegetative incompatibility, three gene regions were chosen that contained closely spaced nucleotides that were polymorphic among some of the six VCGs examined. A member of each VCG was collected from five regions across the southern United States. Isolates belonging to the same VCG had similar sets of single nucleotide polymorphisms regardless of isolate origin. The six VCGs formed four genetically distinct groups. Although recombination between certain pairs of VCGs could not be excluded, none was found for YV36, the VCG that includes the atoxigenic A. flavus isolate currently used to mitigate aflatoxin contamination in cotton in Arizona.