Rates of the reversible deprotonation of benzo[b]-2,3-dihydrofuran-2-one (6H-O) and benzo[b]-2,3-dihydrothiophene-2-one (6H-S) by OH-, primary aliphatic amines, secondary alicyclic amines, and carboxylate ions have been determined in water at 25 degrees C. As noted earlier by Kresge and Meng, 6H-S (pKa = 8.82) is considerably more acidic than 6H-O (pKa = 11.68), which mainly reflects the greater aromatic stabilization of the conjugate base of 6H-S (thiophene derivative) compared to that of 6H-O (furan derivative). The main focus of this paper is to assess how the difference in the aromaticity of the two enolate ions affects the intrinsic barrier to the proton transfer. These intrinsic barriers were determined from Brønsted plots for the reactions with the amines and carboxylate ions or calculated on the basis of the Marcus equation for the reactions with OH-. They are consistently somewhat higher for the reactions of 6H-S than for the reactions of 6H-O, implying that the aromaticity in the anion enhances the intrinsic barrier. This contrasts with a previous report on the deprotonation of some cyclic rhenium Fischer-type carbene complexes where the reaction that leads to the most aromatic conjugate base (thiophene derivative) has a lower intrinsic barrier than the reaction that leads to the less aromatic furan analogue. We are offering a detailed analysis of other potential factors that may affect the intrinsic barriers and which could explain these contradictory results.