A timely, efficient, and coordinated activation of both CD4 and CD8 T cell subsets following HCV infection is believed to be essential for HCV control. However, to what extent a failure of the individual T cell subsets can contribute to the high propensity of HCV to persist is still largely undefined. To address this issue, we analyzed the breadth, vigor, and quality of CD4 and CD8 responses simultaneously with panels of peptides covering the entire HCV sequence or containing the HLA-A2-binding motif, and with recombinant HCV proteins in 16 patients with acute HCV infection by tetramer staining, ELISPOT, and intracellular cytokine staining for interferon gamma, interleukin (IL)-2, IL-4, and IL-10. Our results indicate that at clinical onset, CD8 responses are similarly weak and narrowly focused in both self-limited and chronically evolving infections. At this stage, CD4 responses are deeply impaired in patients with a chronic outcome as they are weak and of narrow specificity, unlike the strong, broad and T helper 1-oriented CD4 responses associated with resolving infections. Only patients able to finally control infection show maturation of CD8 memory sustained by progressive expansion of CD127+ CD8 cells. Thus, a poor CD8 response in the acute stage of infection may enhance the overall probability of chronic viral persistence. In conclusion, the presence of functional CD4 responses represents one of the factors dictating the fate of infection by directly contributing to control of the virus and by promoting maturation of protective memory CD8 responses.