High-density multi-channel intra-cortical electrode arrays allow researchers to record simultaneously from populations of neurons for the purpose of understanding neural coding and plasticity. These devices have tens to hundreds of electrodes spaced within a few square millimeters. During insertion, the high-density probes can compress the cortex several millimeters prior to breaking through the pia. Compression of cortical tissue has been demonstrated to result in traumatic brain injury (TBI) which may be a major contributor to low electrode yield and decreased recording longevity. Two insertion techniques for chronically implanting multi-wire electrode arrays in layer IV of primary auditory cortex were compared. A mechanical insertion device, capable of rapidly inserting the electrode array without visible compression of the brain, was constructed. The neural responses to broadband clicks and pure tones recorded from the arrays inserted with the mechanical device were compared to the results from a manual insertion method using a micromanipulator. Both techniques result in a similar number of active channels directly following surgery with a mean signal-to-noise ratio of approximately 4.5. Over 60% of the animals implanted with the mechanical insertion device had driven activity at week 6 whereas none of the animals with manually inserted arrays exhibited functional responses after 3 weeks. This report provides initial evidence that mechanical insertion devices, which prevent cortical compression, increase electrode recording longevity.