Current techniques in tandem mass spectrometric analyses of cellular protein contents often produce thousands to tens of thousands of spectra per experiment. This study introduces a new algorithm, named SPEQUAL, which is aimed at automated tandem mass spectral quality assessment. The quality of a given spectrum can be evaluated from three basic components: (i) charge state differentiation, (ii) total signal intensity, and (iii) signal-to-noise estimates. The differentiation between single and multiple precursor charge states (i) provides a binary score for a given spectrum. Components (ii) and (iii) provide partial scores which are subsequently summarized and multiplied by the first score. SPEQUAL was applied to over 10,000 data files derived from almost 3,000 tandem mass spectra, and the results (final cumulative scores) were manually verified. SPEQUAL's performance was determined to have high sensitivity and specificity and low error rates for both spectral quality estimates in general and precursor charge state differentiation in particular. Each of the partial scores is controlled by adjustable thresholds to fine-tune SPEQUAL's performance for different analysis pipelines and instrumentation. This spectral quality assessment tool is intended to act in an advisory role to the researcher, assisting in filtration of thousands of spectra typically produced by high throughput tandem mass spectrometric proteome analyses. Lastly, SPEQUAL was implemented as Java GUI-based and command-line-based interfaces freely available for both academic and industrial researchers.