The controlled reaction of molecular oxygen with hydrocarbon solutions of tBuLi results in the unexpected formation of the octameric species [(tBuOLi)8], 18. Single-crystal X-ray diffraction studies indicate that the connectivity within 18 corresponds with the fusion of two face-opened tetrameric cubanes. Cryoscopic studies establish the stability of the octamer in benzene solution, but heating results in aggregate rearrangement to the commonly found prismatic hexameric form, 16. Theoretical calculations confirm that the hexameric form is the thermodynamically favored aggregate.