The aim of this study was to determine the effect of soluble fiber on indexes of colon-cancer risk in postpolypectomy and nonpolyp patients. Forty-five postpolypectomy and 49 nonpolyp volunteers completed 2-wk metabolic studies where half of the group received oat-bran supplements and the other half took wheat-brain supplements. Colonic biopsies taken before and after the intervention showed no difference in the index of thymidine colonic-crypt-cell labeling, thymidine-labeling pattern, or nuclear aberrations. Nevertheless, fecal pH was significantly reduced by 0.23 +/- 0.07 pH units (P less than 0.002) as an index of increased colonic fermentation on oat bran. This was not associated with increased basal breath hydrogen concentrations; fecal butyrate concentrations were higher on wheat bran. We conclude that soluble fiber as oat brain appears to have no advantage over wheat bran in modifying putative risk factors for colonic cancer.