Objective: To evaluate the allocation and outcome of cadaver-donor renal transplantation (CDRTx) among Jewish and Arab children in Israel.
Methods: Data on CDRTxs in patients who had end-stage renal failure (ESRF), were younger than 18 years, and were on dialysis treatment were obtained for the 11-year period of January 1990 to December 2000 from the Israeli Dialysis and Transplant Registry, supplemented by 10 years of follow-up (January 1991-December 2000) from our own center.
Results: The Israeli Dialysis and Transplant Registry data show that 64 of 130 available cadaver-donor kidneys (CDKs) were allocated to Jewish patients (49.2%) and 66 of 130 were allocated to Arab children (50.8%): Moslem, Druze, or Christian. The Jew/Arab patient ratio for a waiting time of <1 year was 0.97 and for 1 to 2 years was 1.45, whereas that ratio was 0.6 for 2 to 4 years and 2.0 for >4 years. The mean renal transplant score (RTx score), reflecting the urgency of the need for RTx of an ESRF patient, was identical for Jew and Arab: 4.93 and 4.96. Our own center data refer to 69 dialysis (47 Arabs and 22 Jews) and 4 predialysis patients younger than 18 years who underwent 78 RTxs. Eighteen Arab and 14 Jewish children from our center received 20 and 15 CDRTxs in Israel, with a mean waiting time of 29.6 and 25.4 months for Jew and Arab, respectively (ratio: 1.16). In our center, the outcome (after 7 years) of graft survival and function was not different between Jewish and Arab RTx recipients.
Conclusions: Allocation of CDRTxs between young Jewish and Arab ESRF patients on dialysis did not differ and was associated with comparable waiting times, identical RTx scores, and similar long-term outcome. This is a remarkable finding, certainly in the face of the unequal race allocation of RTxs in the United States as well as the long unstable local (Middle East) political situation.