Bacteriophage assembly frequently begins with the formation of a precursor capsid that serves as a DNA packaging machine. The DNA packaging is accompanied by a morphogenesis of the small round precursor capsid into a large polyhedral DNA-containing mature phage. In vitro, this transformation can be induced by heat or chemical treatment of P22 procapsids. In this work, we examine bacteriophage P22 morphogenesis by comparing three-dimensional structures of capsids expanded both in vitro by heat treatment and in vivo by DNA packaging. The heat-expanded capsid reveals a structure that is virtually the same as the in vivo expanded capsid except that the pentons, normally present at the icosahedral fivefold positions, have been released. The similarities of these two capsid structures suggest that the mechanism of heat expansion is similar to in vivo expansion. The loss of the pentons further suggests the necessity of specific penton-hexon interactions during expansion. We propose a model whereby the penton-hexon interactions are stabilized through interactions of DNA, coat protein, and other minor proteins. When considered in the context of other studies using chemical or heat treatment of capsids, our study indicates that penton release may be a common trend among double-stranded DNA containing viruses.