Model melanoidins from monomeric, oligomeric, and polymeric carbohydrates, and amino acids formed under aqueous as well as water-free reaction conditions, were submitted to acidic catalyzed hydrolysis. Their degradation products were detected qualitatively and quantitatively by HPTLC and HPLC-DAD. A considerable amount of monomer carbohydrates from hydrolysis of model melanoidins formed under water-free reaction conditions was detected. It can be seen clearly that the amount of carbohydrates released increased with increasing degree of polymerization of the carbohydrates used as starting material. In comparison, the hydrolysis of melanoidins formed in aqueous condition resulted in only a small glucose release. It seems that in the Maillard reaction under water-free conditions, a significant amount of di- and oligomer carbohydrates were incorporated into the melanoidin skeleton as complete oligomer with intact glycosidic bond, forming side chains at the melanoidin skeleton. Additional side chains could be formed by transglycosylation reactions. With increasing water content, hydrothermolytic as well as retro-aldol reactions of the starting carbonyl components became significant, and therefore the possibility of forming side chains decreased. The results are consistent with the postulated melanoidin structure being built up mainly from sugar degradation products, probably branched via amino compounds.