Within the cerebral palsy syndromes, athetosis is most commonly causally associated with serious perinatal complications. Genetic factors are thought to play a lesser role, although the risk of recurrence in siblings has been suggested to be as high as 10%. We have conducted a clinical study of 22 subjects with a diagnosis of athetoid cerebral palsy and a review of the literature aiming to identify instances of familial recurrence of athetoid cerebral palsy. The birth history, family history, and previous investigations of subjects with athetoid cerebral palsy were studied and subjects were clinically examined for evidence of an underlying genetic etiology. Factors suggesting a genetic cause were specifically sought, such as advanced paternal age, progression of symptoms, and associated congenital abnormalities. No subjects in the study group had similarly affected relatives, and additional features suggesting a genetic cause were not observed. A literature search identified 16 instances of familial recurrence of athetoid cerebral palsy. Familial cases were typically associated with significant spasticity, microcephaly, intellectual disability, seizures, and a lack of history of birth asphyxia, and most could be explained by either autosomal-recessive or X-linked-recessive inheritance. The genetic contribution to athetoid cerebral palsy is small, with an overall risk of recurrence in siblings of about 1%. This risk is lower than previously suggested in the literature.