The extent to which the structural Ca(2+) ions of horseradish peroxidase (HRPC) are a determinant in defining the heme pocket architecture is investigated by electronic absorption and resonance Raman spectroscopy upon removal of one Ca(2+) ion. The Fe(III) heme states are modified upon Ca(2+) depletion, with an uncommon quantum mechanically mixed spin state becoming the dominant species. Ca(2+)-depleted HRPC forms complexes with benzohydroxamic acid and CO which display spectra very similar to those of native HRPC, indicating that any changes to the distal cavity structural properties upon Ca(2+) depletion are easily reversed. Contrary to the native protein, the Ca(2+)-depleted ferrous form displays a low-spin bis-histidyl heme state and a small proportion of high-spin heme. Furthermore, the nu(Fe-Im) stretching mode downshifts 27 cm(-1) upon Ca(2+) depletion revealing a significant structural perturbation of the proximal cavity near the histidine ligand. The specific activity of the Ca(2+)-depleted enzyme is 50% that of the native form. The effects on enzyme activity and spectral features observed upon Ca(2+) depletion are reversible upon reconstitution. Evaluation of the present and previous data firmly favors the proximal Ca(2+) ion as that which is lost upon Ca(2+) depletion and which likely plays the more critical role in regulating the heme pocket structural and catalytic properties.