Multiple allelism in heterozygous autopolyploid species like potato not only occurs for genes that affect morphological characteristics but also for genes involved in metabolic pathways. Based on a combination of Southern and PCR analyses, at least eight alleles encoding granule-bound starch synthase I (GBSSI), which is responsible for amylose biosynthesis, have been identified in potato. These alleles were grouped into four classes, distinguishable by Southern analysis, and subdivided based on PCR. Despite the heterozygous and polyploid character of potato it was possible to assign variation in GBSSI activity to the allelic composition at the GBSSI loci within a large population of Solanum tuberosum cultivars and Solanum breeding lines. Moreover, the availability of an amf allele made it possible to reduce heterogeneity and enabled us to demonstrate an effect of GBSSI allelic composition on amylose content. The major difference between the alleles identified was the absence or presence of a 140-bp fragment at a site 0.5 kb upstream of the ATG start codon of the gene for GBSSI. The absence of this 140-bp fragment had a major effect on GBSSI activity and amylose content, while the presence of small deletions and simple sequence repeats had no obvious effect.