Neuronal nitric-oxide synthase (nNOS or NOS I) and endothelial NOS (eNOS or NOS III) differ widely in their reductase and nitric oxide (NO) synthesis activities, electron transfer rates, and propensities to form a heme-NO complex during catalysis. We generated chimeras by swapping eNOS and nNOS oxygenase domains to understand the basis for these differences and to identify structural elements that determine their catalytic behaviors. Swapping oxygenase domains did not alter domain-specific catalytic functions (cytochrome c reduction or H(2)O(2)-supported N(omega)-hydroxy-l-arginine oxidation) but markedly affected steady-state NO synthesis and NADPH oxidation compared with native eNOS and nNOS. Stopped-flow analysis showed that reductase domains either maintained (nNOS) or slightly exceeded (eNOS) their native rates of heme reduction in each chimera. Heme reduction rates were found to correlate with the initial rates of NADPH oxidation and heme-NO complex formation, with the percentage of heme-NO complex attained during the steady state, and with NO synthesis activity. Oxygenase domain identity influenced these parameters to a lesser degree. We conclude: 1) Heme reduction rates in nNOS and eNOS are controlled primarily by their reductase domains and are almost independent of oxygenase domain identity. 2) Heme reduction rate is the dominant parameter controlling the kinetics and extent of heme-NO complex formation in both eNOS and nNOS, and thus it determines to what degree heme-NO complex formation influences their steady-state NO synthesis, whereas oxygenase domains provide minor but important influences. 3) General principles that relate heme reduction rate, heme-NO complex formation, and NO synthesis are not specific for nNOS but apply to eNOS as well.