The primary problem in the measurement of reticulated platelets (RP) stained with thiazole orange (TO) by flow cytometry is the definition of a threshold limit for fluorescence positivity. We evaluated settings for the threshold gate for TO positivity based on two principles: a fluorescence histogram (median FL1, Relative FL1) or a plot of forward light scatter (FSC; reflecting the distribution of the platelet size) versus fluorescence intensity (% RP). These methods were applied prospectively in examination of 54 healthy blood donors (16 females) and a total of 50 blinded patient samples: pregnant women with thrombocytopenia (Group 1A, n = 11), thrombocytopenic women after delivery (Group 1B, n = 9) and healthy women with a thrombocytopenic newborn (Group 2, n = 30). Group 1A displayed higher median FL1 (mean 306, CI 279-332) as compared to that of Group 2 (mean 266, CI 255-277; p = 0.0038) or to that of the female controls (mean 249, CI 231-268; p < 0.001). Relative FL1 was also higher in the patients of Group 1A than those of Group 2 (p = 0.037). When analysing the % RP, the difference between these groups was not significant. In the patients (n = 50), the median FSC (mean 407, SD 40, CI 395-418) was also higher than that of the controls (n = 54; mean 383, SD 25, CI 376-390; Mann-Whitney U-test, p = 0.0015). In Group 1A, a significant correlation was observed between the Patient median FL1 and Patient median FSC (r = 0.62, p = 0.043). When developing methods for the measurement of RP, it seems to be useful to analyse the data with more than one principle to define the threshold limit for TO positivity.