Free radical intermediates were detected by the electron paramagnetic resonance spin trapping technique upon protonation/deprotonation reactions of carotenoid and beta-ionone radical ions. The hyperfine coupling constants of their spin adducts obtained by spectral simulation indicate that carbon-centered radicals were trapped. The formation of these species was shown to be a result of chemical oxidation of neutral compounds by Fe(3+) or I(2) followed by deprotonation of the corresponding radical cations or addition of nucleophilic agents to them. Bulk electrolysis reduction of beta-ionone and carotenoids also leads to the formation of free radicals via protonation of the radical anions. Two different spin adducts were detected in the reaction of carotenoid polyenes with piperidine in the presence of 2-methyl-2-nitroso-propane (MNP). One is attributable to piperidine radicals (C(5)H(10)N*) trapped by MNP and the other was identified as trapped neutral carotenoid (beta-ionone) radical produced via protonation of the radical anion. Formation of these radical anions was confirmed by ultraviolet-visible spectroscopy. It was found that the ability of carotenoid radical anions/cations to produce neutral radicals via protonation/deprotonation is more pronounced for unsymmetrical carotenoids with terminal electron-withdrawing groups. This effect was confirmed by the radical cation deprotonation energy (H(D)) estimated by semiempirical calculations. The results indicate that the ability of carotenoid radical cations to deprotonate decreases in the sequence: beta-ionone > unsymmetrical carotenoids > symmetrical carotenoids. The minimum H(D) values were obtained for proton abstraction from the C(4) atom and the C(5)-methyl group of the cyclohexene ring. It was assumed that deprotonation reaction occurs preferentially at these positions.