We compared the leucine (Leu) and phenylalanine (Phe) tracer-determined response of forearm protein synthesis (PS) before and after stimulation of protein anabolism by intravenous infusion of Leu-enriched, Phe-deficient amino acids and insulin (increased to approximately 100 microU/mL) with the euglycemic clamp. Six healthy subjects received primed-constant infusions of L-[ring-2H5]-Phe and L-[1-(14)C]-Leu, and steady-state forearm Phe and Leu kinetics were determined. Following the combined infusion, the arterial Leu concentration increased approximately 70% (P < .001), whereas Phe decreased about 15% (P < .01). Forearm PS and net balance (NB) increased (P < .05 or less v basal) using both amino acid tracers. However, the relative increments observed with the Leu tracer were more than 75% larger (P < .05 or less) than those observed with the Phe tracer, even when the data were corrected for the standard relative abundance of these two amino acids in forearm protein(s). Thus, the calculated changes of forearm PS and NB in response to an unbalanced amino acid infusion with hyperinsulinemia were affected by the plasma level of leucine and phenylalanine, whose tracers were used to estimate forearm protein turnover. Since these two essential amino acids share the same transport system, a competition at this level cannot be excluded.