Objective: To analyze clinical, electrophysiologic, and neuroradiologic characteristics and prognostic factors in a group of patients with temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) and complex partial seizures (CPS) occurring exclusively or predominantly after they fall asleep or before they awaken.
Background: CPS arising during sleep are classically identified with frontal lobe epilepsy. TLE associated with seizures occurring only or predominantly during sleep (nocturnal TLE) is less common.
Methods: From a series of patients with refractory TLE studied between 1980 and 1996, the authors identified 26 patients (15 men) with nonlesional nocturnal TLE (mean age, 40 years). Clinical and laboratory characteristics of these individuals were studied and compared with a group of 72 age-matched, randomly selected patients with nonlesional TLE and predominantly diurnal seizures (diurnal TLE).
Results: Mean age at seizure onset was similar for both groups (16.3 versus 18.7 years). In the nocturnal TLE group, 2 of 26 patients had a positive family history of epilepsy, 18 reported an aura, 4 presented with CPS in clusters, 11 had unilateral and 15 bilateral temporal EEG abnormalities, and 14 of 21 studied had unilateral mesial temporal atrophy. None of these factors differed significantly in the two groups except for higher frequency of the following in the diurnal TLE group compared with the nocturnal TLE group: positive family history for epilepsy (33% versus 8%, p=0.01), estimated frequency of seizures (median, 14 versus 2 per month; p < 0.01), and presence of antecedent febrile convulsions (33% versus 11%, p=0.04). In the nocturnal TLE group, eight patients underwent surgical therapy and became seizure free (follow-up, > 12 months). Only two were seizure free on medication.
Conclusions: Infrequent and nonclustered seizures, rare family history of epilepsy, and low prevalence of childhood febrile convulsions characterize nocturnal TLE. Within the TLEs, the nocturnal TLE form seems to have a better surgical prognosis.