Access challenges for patients with limited English proficiency: a secret-shopper study of in-person and telehealth behavioral health services in California safety-net clinics

Health Aff Sch. 2023 Aug 14;1(3):qxad033. doi: 10.1093/haschl/qxad033. eCollection 2023 Sep.

Abstract

The recent growth of telehealth may be impacting access to care for patients, including those with limited English proficiency (LEP). Using a secret-shopper design, simulated patients contacted 386 safety-net clinics in California in both Spanish and English from February-March 2023. Callers stated that they were new patients seeking medication for depression, and they documented time to an appointment and available visit modalities (telehealth and in-person). Multinomial logistic regression models examined associations between clinic characteristics and available modalities. English-speaking callers were more likely to speak with a live scheduler and to obtain appointment information from a scheduler who could engage with them in their preferred language. Among Spanish-speaking callers who reached a live scheduler, 22% reached someone who did not engage (eg, were hung up on) and, as a result, could not obtain appointment information. The mean estimated time to a prescribing visit was 36 days and did not differ by language. Sixty-four percent of clinics offered both telehealth and in-person visits, 14% only offered in-person visits, and 22% only offered telehealth visits. More attention and resources are needed to support patients with LEP at the point of scheduling and to ensure choice of visit modality for all patient populations.

Keywords: health centers; health equity; language assistance; limited English proficiency; safety net; telehealth.