The metabolic signature identification of colorectal cancer is critical for its early diagnosis and therapeutic approaches that will significantly block cancer progression and improve patient survival. Here, we combined an untargeted metabolic analysis strategy based on internal extractive electrospray ionization mass spectrometry and the machine learning approach to analyze metabolites in 173 pairs of cancer samples and matched normal tissue samples to build robust metabolic signature models for diagnostic purposes. Screening and independent validation of metabolic signatures from colorectal cancers via machine learning methods (Logistic Regression_L1 for feature selection and eXtreme Gradient Boosting for classification) was performed to generate a panel of seven signatures with good diagnostic performance (the accuracy of 87.74%, sensitivity of 85.82%, and specificity of 89.66%). Moreover, seven signatures were evaluated according to their ability to distinguish between cancer and normal tissues, with the metabolic molecule PC (30:0) showing good diagnostic performance. In addition, genes associated with PC (30:0) were identified by multiomics analysis (combining metabolic data with transcriptomic data analysis) and our results showed that PC (30:0) could promote the proliferation of colorectal cancer cell SW480, revealing the correlation between genetic changes and metabolic dysregulation in cancer. Overall, our results reveal potential determinants affecting metabolite dysregulation, paving the way for a mechanistic understanding of altered tissue metabolites in colorectal cancer and design interventions for manipulating the levels of circulating metabolites.