FT-ICR MS and NMR analysis of an isotopically labeled complex mixture of water disinfection byproducts formed by chloramine disinfection of model phenolic acids is described. A new molecular formula assignment procedure using the CoreMS Python library able to assign isotopically enriched formulas is proposed. Statistical analysis of the assigned formulas showed that the number of compounds, the diversity of the mixture, and the chlorine count increase during the chloramination reaction. The complex reaction mixture was investigated as a network of reactions using PageRank and Reverse PageRank algorithms. Independent of the MS signal intensities, the PageRank algorithm calculates the formulas with the highest probability at convergence of the reaction; these were chlorinated and nitrated derivatives of the starting materials. The Reverse PageRank revealed that the most probable chemical transformations in the complex mixture were chlorination and decarboxylation. These agree with the data obtained from INADEQUATE NMR spectra and literature data, indicating that this approach could be applied to gain insight into reactions pathways taking place in complex mixtures without any prior knowledge.