Flexible electronics implanted during tissue formation enable chronic studies of tissue-wide electrophysiology. Here, we integrate tissue-like stretchable electronics during organogenesis of human stem cell-derived pancreatic islets, stably tracing single-cell extracellular spike bursting dynamics over months of functional maturation. Adapting spike sorting methods from neural studies reveals maturation-dependent electrical patterns of α and β-like (SC-α and β) cells, and their stimulus-coupled dynamics. We identified two major electrical states for both SC-α and β cells, distinguished by their glucose threshold for action potential firing. We find that improved hormone stimulation capacity during extended culture reflects increasing numbers of SC-α/β cells in low basal firing states, linked to energy and hormone metabolism gene upregulation. Continuous recording during further maturation by entrainment to daily feeding cycles reveals that circadian islet-level hormone secretion rhythms reflect sustained and coordinate oscillation of cell-level SC-α and β electrical activities. We find that this correlates with cell-cell communication and exocytic network induction, indicating a role for circadian rhythms in coordinating system-level stimulus-coupled responses. Cyborg islets thus reveal principles of electrical maturation that will be useful to build fully functional in vitro islets for research and therapeutic applications.