MTSS1 (metastasis suppressor 1) is an I-BAR protein that regulates cytoskeleton dynamics through interactions with actin, Rac, and actin-associated proteins. In a prior study, we identified genetic variants in a cardiac-specific enhancer upstream of MTSS1 that reduce human left ventricular (LV) MTSS1 expression and associate with protection against dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM). We sought to probe these effects further using population genomics and in vivo murine models. We crossed Mtss1-/- mice with a transgenic (Tg) murine model of human DCM caused by the D230N pathogenic mutation in Tpm1 (tropomyosin 1). In females, Tg/Mtss1+/- mice had significantly increased LV ejection fraction and reduced LV volumes relative to their Tg/Mtss1+/+ counterparts, signifying partial rescue of DCM due to Mtss1 haploinsufficiency. No differences were observed in males. To study effects in humans, we fine-mapped the MTSS1 locus with 82 cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) traits in 22,381 UK Biobank participants. MTSS1 enhancer variants showed interaction with biological sex in their associations with several CMR traits. After stratification by biological sex, associations with CMR traits and colocalization with MTSS1 expression in the Genotype-Tissue Expression (GTEx) Project were observed principally in women and were substantially weaker in men. These findings suggest sex dimorphism in the effects of MTSS1-lowering alleles, and parallel the increased LV ejection fraction and reduced LV volumes observed female Tg/Mtss1+/- mice. Together, our findings at the MTSS1 locus suggest a genetic basis for sex dimorphism in cardiac remodeling and motivate sex-specific study of common variants associated with cardiac traits and disease.