Repeated Lacrimal Gland Biopsies

Abstract

Introduction: To examine the indications for repeated lacrimal gland biopsies, and the rate of detection of a new diagnosis.

Methods: A single-center, retrospective review of patients who underwent more than 1 lacrimal gland biopsy, either ipsilateral or contralateral, between 2000 and 2022.

Results: One hundred and twenty-three patients (80 female; 65%) had repeated lacrimal gland biopsy. The commonest diagnosis on initial biopsy was chronic nonspecific dacryoadenitis (NSD) (49/123; 40%). Indications for repeated biopsy were uncertainty in making a histopathological diagnosis (16/123; 13%), poorly-responsive or recurrent ipsilateral disease (61/123; 50%), new or continued/worsening contralateral disease (30 patients; 24%), and planned tumor resection after initial biopsy (16/123; 13%). Of the 40 patients (33%) with a different histopathological diagnosis after repeated lacrimal biopsy, 4 (10%) had lymphoma, initially reported as NSD (4/49 with NSD; 8%), and 7/40 (18%) (14% of the 49 NSD patients) were reclassified as having specific inflammations (including 2 with granulomatous polyangiitis); of the 7 having reclassification as a specific dacryoadenitis, 6/7 had ipsilateral disease failing to respond to primary treatment, and 1/7 had new onset or progression of contralateral disease. All histology after the primary biopsy of 16 patients with lacrimal gland malignancies retained the same tissue diagnosis.

Conclusion: Repeated biopsy for lacrimal gland disease in this study revealed a diagnosis of malignancy in 20%, including lymphoma in 8% of those initially diagnosed with NSD. There was a 14% rate of diagnostic progression from "non-specific" dacryoadenitis to a more specific inflammatory disease.