Editorial Commentary: Absent Extreme Bony Malalignment: Medial Patellofemoral Reconstruction Is a Sufficient Primary Surgery for Adolescents With Recurrent Patella Instability

Abstract

When planning an adolescent's primary surgery for recurrent patella instability, the surgeon must weigh the failure risk of performing medial patellofemoral reconstruction (MPFLR) versus the potential morbidity of adding a concomitant bony procedure, such as tibial tubercle osteotomy. In this age group, isolated MPFLR is an excellent operation with high clinical success, low failure rates, and favorable complication profile. Patients with high grade J-sign and severe trochlea dysplasia, apprehension into deep flexion, and extremes of bony malalignment, including elevated tibial tubercle-trochlear groove distance, may benefit from "doing more" than MPFLR alone. Other factors to be considered include patella alta, generalized ligament laxity, femoral rotation, tibial torsion, and valgus malalignment. In challenging situations, such as syndromic patients (e.g., neuromuscular disorders), congenital (habitual) patella dislocation, fixed dislocations, and failed prior to MPFLR, a combined surgical approach is likely needed. Patients who require "unloading" for symptomatic chondrosis also benefit from combined bony and soft tissue surgery. However, for the majority of patients with recurrent instability and no prior surgery, an isolated soft tissue reconstruction is a rational, safe, efficient, and evidence-based selection.