Metal-mediated base pairs represent a topical alternative to canonical hydrogen-bonded base pairs. In this context, the ligand 1H-imidazo[4,5-f][1,10]phenanthroline (P) was introduced as an artificial nucleobase in a glycol nucleic acid-based nucleoside analogue into a DNA oligonucleotide in a way that the oligonucleotide contains a central block of six contiguous P residues. The ability to engage in Ag+-mediated base pairing was evaluated with respect to the four canonical nucleosides in positions complementary to P. Highly stabilizing Ag+-mediated base pairs were formed with cytosine and guanine (i.e., P-Ag+-C and P-Ag+-G base pairs), whereas the analogous base pairs with thymine and adenine were much less stable and hence formed incompletely. Surprisingly, the intermediate formation of a homodimeric duplex of the P-containing oligonucleotide was observed in all cases, albeit to a different extent. The homodimer is composed of P-Ag+-P base pairs and 18 overhanging mismatched canonical nucleobases. It demonstrates the obstacles present when designing metal-mediated base pairs as metal complexation may take place irrespective of the surrounding natural base pairs. Homodimer formation was found to be particularly prominent when the designated metal-mediated base pairs are of low stability, suggesting that homodimers and regular duplexes are formed in a competing manner.