Towards a sustainable fisher-dolphin coexistence: Understanding depredation, assessing economic damage and evaluating management options

J Environ Manage. 2024 Feb:351:119797. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2023.119797. Epub 2023 Dec 11.

Abstract

Finding solutions for a sustainable coexistence between wildlife and humans is considered among the most challenging environmental management issues for scientists, conservationists, managers, and stockholders world-wide. Depredation by the common bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncatus) on small scale fisheries has increased in the recent years, leading to a growing conflict in many areas of the Mediterranean Sea and pressing for urgent management solutions. This study aims at developing a management framework for a sustainable coexistence between fishers and dolphins in Sardinia (Mediterranean Sea). Relying on the combination of different approaches (field study, literature review and Multi Criteria Decision Analysis), the scientific evidence necessary for understanding dolphin depredation were updated and improved, the related economic damage was calculated, and different management options were identified and evaluated by several stakeholder groups to support the decision-making process. Averaging for all investigated net types (gillnet and trammel net), a depredation frequency of 53% was found, the highest values ever found in both Sardinia and many other Mediterranean sites. Depredation probability was influenced by different factors, such as net type, fishing operation duration, depth of the fishing site and period. The estimated economic damage due to depredation ranges on average between 6492 and 11,925 euro per year and depends on the type of fishing net. The results from the field study, the literature review and the stakeholder involvement allowed us to define the most plausible and shared management options, identifying a framework for assessing and managing the conflict between fishers and dolphins for the creation of a more sustainable vision for the future.

Keywords: Depredation; Economic damage; Human-wildlife conflict; Mediterranean sea; Participatory process.

MeSH terms

  • Animals
  • Animals, Wild
  • Bottle-Nosed Dolphin*
  • Dolphins*
  • Fisheries
  • Humans
  • Mediterranean Sea
  • Probability