An automated pipeline integrating AlphaFold 2 and MODELLER for protein structure prediction

Fabio Hernan Gil Zuluaga; Nancy D'Arminio; Francesco Bardozzo; Roberto Tagliaferri; Anna Marabotti

doi:10.1016/j.csbj.2023.10.056

An automated pipeline integrating AlphaFold 2 and MODELLER for protein structure prediction

Comput Struct Biotechnol J. 2023 Nov 3:21:5620-5629. doi: 10.1016/j.csbj.2023.10.056. eCollection 2023.

Authors

Fabio Hernan Gil Zuluaga¹, Nancy D'Arminio², Francesco Bardozzo¹, Roberto Tagliaferri¹, Anna Marabotti²

Affiliations

¹ Department of Management & Innovation Systems, University of Salerno, Via Giovanni Paolo II, 132, 84084 Fisciano, SA, Italy.
² Department of Chemistry and Biology "A. Zambelli", University of Salerno, Via Giovanni Paolo II, 132, 84084 Fisciano, SA, Italy.

Abstract

The ability to predict a protein's three-dimensional conformation represents a crucial starting point for investigating evolutionary connections with other members of the corresponding protein family, examining interactions with other proteins, and potentially utilizing this knowledge for the purpose of rational drug design. In this work, we evaluated the feasibility of improving AlphaFold2's three-dimensional protein predictions by developing a novel pipeline (AlphaMod) that incorporates AlphaFold2 with MODELLER, a template-based modeling program. Additionally, our tool can drive a comprehensive quality assessment of the tertiary protein structure by incorporating and comparing a set of different quality assessment tools. The outcomes of selected tools are combined into a composite score (BORDASCORE) that exhibits a meaningful correlation with GDT_TS and facilitates the selection of optimal models in the absence of a reference structure. To validate AlphaMod's results, we conducted evaluations using two distinct datasets summing up to 72 targets, previously used to independently assess AlphaFold2's performance. The generated models underwent evaluation through two methods: i) averaging the GDT_TS scores across all produced structures for a single target sequence, and ii) a pairwise comparison of the best structures generated by AlphaFold2 and AlphaMod. The latter, within the unsupervised setups, shows a rising accuracy of approximately 34% over AlphaFold2. While, when considering the supervised setup, AlphaMod surpasses AlphaFold2 in 18% of the instances. Finally, there is an 11% correspondence in outcomes between the diverse methodologies. Consequently, AlphaMod's best-predicted tertiary structures in several cases exhibited a significant improvement in the accuracy of the predictions with respect to the best models obtained by AlphaFold2. This pipeline paves the way for the integration of additional data and AI-based algorithms to further improve the reliability of the predictions.

Keywords: AlphaFold 2; Deep learning; MODELLER; Protein structure prediction.