Ammonia is of great importance in fertilizer production and chemical synthesis. It can also potentially serve as a carbon-free energy carrier for a future hydrogen economy. Motivated by a worldwide effort to lower carbon emissions, ammonia synthesis by lithium-mediated electrochemical nitrogen reduction (LiNR) has been considered as a promising alternative to the Haber-Bosch process. A significant performance improvement in LiNR has been achieved in recent years by exploration of favorable lithium salt and proton donor for the electrolyte recipe, but the solvent study is still in its infancy. In this work, a systematic investigation on ether-based solvents toward LiNR is conducted. The assessments of solvent candidates are built on their conductivity, parasitic reactions, product distribution, and faradaic efficiency. Notably, dimethoxyethane gives the lowest potential loss among the investigated systems, while tetrahydrofuran achieves an outstanding faradaic efficiency of 58.5 ± 6.1% at an ambient pressure. We found that solvent molecules impact the above characteristics by dictating the solvation configurations of conductive ions and inducing the formation of solid electrolyte interphase with different compositions. This study highlights the importance of solvents in the LiNR process and advances the electrolyte optimization for better performance.