To boost efficient energy transitions, alternatives to expensive and unsustainable noble metal-based electrocatalysts for the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) are needed. Having this in mind, carbon black - Black Pearls 2000 (BP) was enriched in active nitrogen-containing centers, including single-atom Fe-N sites surrounded by Fe nanoclusters, through a synthesis methodology employing only broadly available precursors. The methodical approach taken to optimize the synthesis conditions highlighted the importance of (1) a proper choice of the Fe precursor; (2) melamine as an N source to limit the formation of magnetite crystals and modulate the charge density nearby the active sites, and glucose to chelate/isolate Fe atoms and thus allow the Fe-N coordination to be established, with a limiting formation of Fe0 clusters; and (3) a careful dosing of the Fe load. The ORR on the optimized electrocatalyst (Fe0.06-N@BP) proceeds mostly through a four-electron pathway, having an onset potential (0.912 V vs. RHE) and limiting current density (4.757 mA cm-2) above those measured on Pt/C (0.882 V and 4.657 mA cm-2, respectively). Moreover, the current density yielded by Fe0.06-N@BP after 24 h at 0.4 V vs. RHE was still above that of Pt/C at t = 0 (4.44 mA cm-2), making it a promising alternative to noble metal-containing electrocatalysts in fuel cells.