Prenyltransferases in cyanobactin biosynthesis are of growing interest as peptide alkylation biocatalysts, but their prenylation modes characterized so far have been limited to dimethylallylation (C5) or geranylation (C10). Here we engaged in structure-guided engineering of the prenyl-binding pocket of a His-C2-geranyltransferase LimF to modulate its prenylation mode. Contraction of the pocket by a single mutation led to a His-C2-dimethylallyltransferase. More importantly, pocket expansion by a double mutation successfully repurposed LimF for farnesylation (C15), which is an unprecedented mode in this family. Furthermore, the obtained knowledge of the essential residues to construct the farnesyl-binding pocket has allowed for rational design of a Tyr-O-farnesyltransferase by a triple mutation of a Tyr-O-dimethylallyltransferase PagF. These results provide an approach to manipulate the prenyl specificity of cyanobactin prenyltransferases, broadening the chemical space covered by this class of enzymes and expanding the toolbox of peptide alkylation biocatalysts.