A paradigm shift for cardiovascular outcome evaluation in diabetes: Major adverse cardiovascular events (MACE) to major adverse vascular events (MAVE)

Abstract

Background and aims: Drugs for diabetes are required to demonstrate cardiovascular safety through CV outcome trials (CVOT). The pre-defined end-points for cardiovascular outcome studies may not be sufficient to capture all clinically relevant atherosclerotic cardio vascular disease (ASCVD) events particularly peripheral arterial disease (PAD).

Methods: We planned a scoping review and searched database to identify CVOT conducted in population with diabetes measuring lower limb events due to PAD as the primary outcome measure. We also searched CVOT for reported differential cardiovascular outcomes in population with PAD.

Results: We identified that CV outcomes are measured as 3 point major adverse cardiovascular outcomes (3P-MACE) that includes nonfatal MI and nonfatal stroke or 4P-MACE that included additional unstable angina which is further expanded to 5P-MACE by the inclusion of hospitalization for heart failure (HHF). These CV end points are captured as surrogate for CV mortality based on the biological plausibility of relation between the surrogate and final outcome from pathophysiological studies. We found the prevalence of PAD is no lesser than other CV events in people with diabetes. Moreover, PAD contributes to the significant morbidity associated with diabetes as a surrogate for mortality. However, none of the CVOT with anti-diabetic drugs include PAD events as primary outcome measure despite the inclusion of 6-25 % participants with PAD in major CVOT. PAD outcomes are objectively measurable with tibial arterial waveforms and clinical end-point as lower extremity amputation. PAD outcomes do improve with treatment including intensive glycemic control and novel oral anticoagulants. We suggest the inclusion of PAD to MACE as a pre-specified outcome for a comprehensive capture of major adverse vascular event in future studies for people with diabetes.

Conclusions: MACE should be expanded to include PAD event as major adverse vascular event in cardiovascular outcome studies since PAD is clinically relevant and objectively measurable in diabetes.

Keywords: Atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease (ASCVD); Cardiovascular trial (CVOT); Diabetes; Major adverse cardiovascular outcomes (MACE); Peripheral arterial disease (PAD).