Improving access to prosthetic limbs in Germany: An explorative review

Abstract

Background: Meeting the needs of users when it comes to accessing prosthetic limbs is an important factor in the acceptance and use of a prosthesis; the cost of such prosthetics also constitutes a potential financial challenge.

Objectives: The aim of this study was to investigate potential hurdles to accessing limb prosthetics in the German health care system, including organizational, social, economic, and regulatory issues, and to provide food for thought about ethical implications.

Methods: Sixteen German users of limb prosthetics with upper-limb and/or lower-limb amputation were recruited by means of purposive sampling. Semistructured interviews were performed, with the guiding question being as follows: "What were your experiences with the German prosthetic care and reimbursement system?" Ten stakeholders (insurance representatives, prosthetic technicians, medical service representatives, a law expert, and a lawyer) were asked about the issues they encounter in their work related to prosthetic care and reimbursement, and about ways to ameliorate these issues. A qualitative content analysis method was used to analyze the data.

Results: Half of the interviewed service users experienced hurdles to gaining a suitable prosthetic device, such as waiting times and pressure to negotiate their need for a certain prosthesis. Some of the views expressed about the issues relating to prosthetic reimbursement in Germany were common to all stakeholders, whereas some conflicted with the views of others.

Conclusions: Equitable access to prostheses and the efficient distribution of prosthetic innovations could be improved by organizational and regulatory measures. Furthermore, a user-centered design of prostheses, a health technology assessment, monitoring of prosthetic care pathways, and a societal discussion about rationing in health care should be considered as parts of a broader approach to tackle this issue.