BACKGROUND Neurofibromatosis 1 is a neurocutaneous disorder with multisystemic manifestations. When patients are lacking overt cutaneous manifestations, diagnosis may be delayed and may complicate diagnosis and management of atypical presentations of this disease. It is thus important to strive to obtain relevant and/or complete history to arrive at the appropriate diagnosis. Furthermore, maintaining an index of suspicion in cases of vague abdominal pain may guide the clinician in establishing the correct diagnosis of mesenteric plexiform neurofibroma in the setting of known/presumed neurofibromatosis 1 patients presenting with acute and/or chronic vague abdominal symptoms. CASE REPORT This is a case of a teenage boy who presented with acute, vague abdominal pain over a period of 2 weeks. Laboratory tests and physical exam findings in primary and secondary care settings were unremarkable, and thus the patient was discharged home only to continue with abdominal pain, thus seeking additional medical care. After admission to our facility and exhaustive history taking, physical examination, and imaging, a prospective diagnosis of neurofibromatosis with mesenteric neurofibroma was made. Upon surgical exploration, a mesenteric mass with corresponding volvulized, ischemic small bowel was removed. Histopathology confirmed a plexiform neurofibroma. The patient recovered adequately and was discharged home without complications. CONCLUSIONS This case highlights the importance of exhaustive history taking to obtain an accurate diagnosis as well as the importance of a high index of clinical suspicion for mesenteric neurofibromatosis in patients with presumed or known neurofibromatosis and presenting with vague abdominal symptoms.