Laser synthesis in liquids is often carried out in organic solvents to prevent oxidation of metals during nanoparticle generation and to produce tailored carbon-based nanomaterials. This work investigates laser ablation of neat organic liquids acetone, ethanol, n-hexane, and toluene with pulse widths ranging from 30 fs to 4 ps through measurements of reaction kinetics and characterization of the ablation products with optical spectroscopy and mass spectrometry. Increasing the pulse width from 30 fs to 4 ps impacts both the reaction kinetics and product distributions, suppressing the formation of solvent molecule dimers and oxidized molecules while enhancing the yields of gaseous molecules, sp-hybridized carbons, and fluorescent carbon dots. The observed trends are explained in the context of established ionization mechanisms and cavitation bubble dynamical processes that occur during ultrashort pulsed laser ablation of liquid media. The results of this work have important implications both for controlling the formation of carbon shells around metal nanoparticles during the ablation of solid targets in liquid and producing carbon nanomaterials directly from the ablation of organic liquids without a solid target.