Pharmacological administration of Fibroblast growth factor 21 (FGF21) alters food choice, including that it decreases the consumption of sucrose and other sweet tastants. Conversely, endogenous secretion of FGF21 by the liver is modulated by diet, such that plasma FGF21 is increased after eating foods that have a low dietary protein: total energy (P: E) ratio. Together, these findings suggest a strategy to promote healthy eating, in which the macronutrient content of a pre-load meal could reduce the later consumption of sweet desserts. Here, we tested the prediction that individuals eating a low P: E pre-load meal, and next offered a highly palatable sweet 'dessert', would eat less of the sugary snack compared to controls, due to increased FGF21 signaling. In addition to decreasing sweet intake, FGF21 increases the consumption of dietary protein. Thus, we predicted that individuals eating a low protein pre-load meal, and subsequently offered a very high-protein pellet as 'dessert' or snack, would eat more of the high protein pellet compared to controls, and that this depends on FGF21. We tested this in C57Bl/6J, and liver-specific FGF21-null (FGF21 ΔL ) null male and female mice and littermate controls. Contrary to expectation, eating a low protein pre-load did not reduce the later consumption of a sweet solution in either males or females, despite robustly increasing plasma FGF21. Rather, eating the low protein pre-load increased later consumption of a high protein pellet. This was more apparent among males and was abrogated in the FGF21 ΔL mice. We conclude that physiologic induction of hepatic FGF21 by a low protein pre-load is not sufficient to reduce later consumption of sweet dessert, though it effectively increases the subsequent intake of dietary protein in male mice.