What the Past Suggests About When a Diagnostic Label Is Oppressive

AMA J Ethics. 2023 Jun 1;25(6):E446-451. doi: 10.1001/amajethics.2023.446.

Abstract

Terminology describing transgender and gender diverse identities has evolved over the past 80 years, becoming progressively less pathologizing and less stigmatizing. While transgender health care no longer uses terms such as gender identity disorder or classifies gender dysphoria as a mental health condition, the term gender incongruence continues to be a source of oppression. An all-encompassing term, if one can be found, might be experienced by some as either empowering or abusive. This article draws on historical perspectives to suggest how clinicians might use diagnostic and intervention language that is harmful to patients.

MeSH terms

  • Gender Dysphoria* / diagnosis
  • Gender Dysphoria* / psychology
  • Gender Identity
  • Humans
  • Language
  • Transgender Persons* / psychology
  • Transsexualism*